Java 8 vs Java 11 vs Java 17 vs Java 21: A Comprehensive Comparison

Getting Started with Java Versions

Java has long been the go-to language for developers, prized for its stability, performance, and portability. Over the years, it has evolved significantly, with major updates introducing new features that enhance its functionality and performance. Choosing the right version of Java for your project can be a challenge, especially with so many options available. From the widely adopted Java 8 to the newest Java 21, each version brings unique capabilities tailored for different use cases. This comparison will help you understand the key differences between these versions, enabling you to make a more informed decision about which version best suits your development needs.

Java 8: The Longtime Standard

Release Date: March 2014
LTS: Yes
End of Public Updates: December 2020 (for Oracle JDK, though other vendors may continue support)

Key Features

1. Lambda Expressions: This feature introduced a functional programming paradigm to Java, simplifying syntax and enabling concise and expressive code.
2. Streams API: Java 8’s Streams API allowed for more sophisticated data manipulation, making it easy to process collections, apply transformations, and manage data flows.
3. Optional Class: It helps to avoid NullPointerException by providing a container that may or may not contain a non-null value.
4. New Date and Time API: Java 8 revamped date and time management, replacing the old java.util.Date with a more consistent and flexible API in java.time.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • High stability and extensive community support.
  • Large ecosystem of libraries built with Java 8 compatibility.
• Cons:
  • Lacks modern enhancements, security patches, and optimizations found in newer versions.
  • No modularity, meaning larger runtime and application footprint.

Best for: Applications that require a stable, tested, and widely compatible version, especially if new features and performance optimizations aren’t crucial.

Java 11: The Modern Mainstay

Release Date: September 2018
LTS: Yes
End of Public Updates: September 2026

Key Features

1. Local-Variable Syntax for Lambda Parameters: This enhanced lambda expressions with var, making syntax more concise.
2. HTTP Client API: Java 11 introduced a new, standardized HTTP client API for making HTTP calls, supporting HTTP/2 and WebSocket.
3. String Methods: Methods like isBlank, lines, strip, repeat, etc., streamlined handling of text-based data.
4. Garbage Collector Enhancements: Default G1 garbage collector improvements boosted application performance.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Improved performance with a more efficient garbage collector.
  • Newer APIs like the HTTP client make it easier to handle modern web-based applications.
  • More lightweight, as several obsolete features from Java 8 were removed.
• Cons:
  • Lack of backward compatibility with some Java 8 libraries and frameworks, requiring updates for full compatibility.

Best for: Applications that need improved performance, a more modern set of features, and long-term support, especially for web-based applications.

Java 17: Leaner and Meaner

Release Date: September 2021
LTS: Yes
End of Public Updates: September 2029

Key Features

1. Sealed Classes: These enable developers to create a restricted class hierarchy, allowing only specified classes to extend a base class.
2. Pattern Matching for instance: Simplifies code by allowing type casting directly after an instanceof check.
3. Enhanced Switch Expressions: Switch statements were enhanced to be used as expressions, reducing boilerplate code and improving readability.
4. Removal of Deprecated APIs: Java 17 removed several outdated APIs, resulting in a cleaner codebase and reduced security risks.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Improved code readability and expressiveness through pattern matching and enhanced switch expressions.
  • Sealed classes allow for better control over class hierarchies, making the code safer and more predictable.
  • Higher performance due to continued optimizations.
• Cons:
  • Still relatively new, which may mean certain third-party libraries might need updates for full compatibility.

Best for: Developers seeking cutting-edge features in an LTS version with enhanced control over code structure and clarity, making it ideal for more complex and scalable applications.

Java 21: The Newest LTS Powerhouse

Release Date: September 2023
LTS: Yes
End of Public Updates: September 2031

Key Features

1. Virtual Threads (Preview): Part of Project Loom, this feature provides lightweight threads for more efficient concurrency handling, boosting performance in applications with high concurrency.
2. String Templates (Preview): Simplifies string concatenation and embedding expressions, reducing verbosity and potential bugs.
3. Record Patterns: These enable pattern matching for Record types, enhancing data-handling efficiency.
4. Structured Concurrency: Provides a structured model for concurrent programming, making it easier to manage threads and dependencies in asynchronous programming.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Modern concurrency management with Virtual Threads and Structured Concurrency for highly responsive applications.
  • Significant enhancements in developer productivity with string templates and record patterns.
  • Continued improvements in performance, garbage collection, and security.
• Cons:
  • Cutting-edge features like Virtual Threads are still in preview, which may not be ideal for production environments.

Best for: Applications needing advanced concurrency and high responsiveness, ideal for modern cloud-native applications and microservices. Perfect for teams wanting to leverage the latest Java innovations and are comfortable with early adoption.

Java Version Comparison Table

But choosing the right Java version is just one part of the equation, what truly sets you apart is mastering how to build and deploy applications efficiently. If you’re looking to go beyond just understanding Java versions and want to gain hands-on experience in full-stack development, check out the GUVI Zen Class Java Full Stack Development Course. This immersive program equips you with real-world skills, helping you become job-ready while staying updated with the latest Java advancements.

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Java Version

• Java 8 is still a safe choice for legacy systems or teams that need extensive compatibility with older tools and libraries. However, without public support, it’s more vulnerable to security issues.
• Java 11 offers a blend of modern features with long-term support, making it a practical choice for enterprise applications that need both stability and moderate performance enhancements.
• Java 17 brings enhanced features for cleaner, more maintainable code, ideal for projects that can leverage more advanced control over class hierarchies and pattern matching.
• Java 21 is the future-facing choice with groundbreaking features for high concurrency and modern application development needs, though teams should ensure they’re ready for preview features if using Virtual Threads or Structured Concurrency.

Each version has its own strengths. The ideal choice ultimately depends on the project’s needs, the team’s familiarity, and the infrastructure. For teams prioritizing cutting-edge features, Java 21 represents the future of Java development, while Java 17 and Java 11 remain solid choices for stability with enhanced features.